Director of Rugby's Blog

Time for a break

05 Nov 2018

Not our best performance of the season by a long way but a win. Hawick as we said last week are always fired up when they play us. But a win is a win especially when not performing on all cylinders , the boys can now have a well earned week  off .  

For those who read the press and are concerned or puzzled over the doubts around Super 6 , I have to say I have attended a number of meetings regarding the subject and all seems very positive. I can understand the frustration at the lack of information and we will update everybody soon. .

For those who are scratching their heads I have to say I share your bewilderment but perhaps not in the way you would expect. As you know I have never been known as a Union defender but having been involved in so many of the discussions I have to assess things in a way that I believe to be factual.

It’s a fact that a good number of clubs asked the Union to bring in amateurism below a top level of club rugby. They brought the plan forward only to be told that  some of the same folk had changed their minds as they didn’t realise it meant they would not be able to give some benefits to some players. Sorry I can't the blame the Union on that one, we all know what amateurism is supposed to mean.


The Premiership and National 1 met the Union and asked them to stop blaming clubs for not having a way forward. We said the only way the future could be planned was for them to answer whether there would be a 3rd pro team--if the answer was yes just let us all go off and enjoy ourselves. If not what do you need us to do to fit into a pathway for the best players--we got the answer, everyone had the chance to apply and 6 clubs were awarded a licence to run a team in a competition AGAIN they did as requested.. it's just we(CLUBS) don’t appear to like the answer with some of the most vocal  ones who applied but were not successful on this occasion not happy. The fact there are 3 franchises in Edinburgh has clouded matters as it allows negativity to enter the stage but for me it's time to move on and take on board the most important issue. This is a pathway for the best players and they are the ones who matter

You may have seen there is a bid of something like £270 million for 51% of the rights to the English Premiership, add that to the huge amount of money available in France and you don’t have to be a rocket scientist to work out whats around the corner. The  pro game outside Scotland is rightly or wrongly going to explode and our pro teams will as always  struggle to keep up. So if you still think a 3rd pro team is the way forward park the thought as there isn't a hope in hell. Our two teams need to run like Usain Bolt and we will still be lapped.

The English clubs will be able to afford to soak up young talent in their Academies and young  Scottish players will head south . Parents , agents(it’s the norm to have one ) will perhaps understandably see it as a better opportunity. So what do we do ? we won't have the cash to stop it, but we can begin to create something that works for those who want to stay and most definitely the ones who return disappointed as it will be ruthless. Super 6 at least brings things together by harnessing club faciities and monies already being spent . For me that’s worth trying.

 A change is required , rugby is changing, players are changing, the world we exist in is changing . It's like everything in life if we believe we know better and set out to prove the point ,yes it may fail. If we try to make it work to help young players it may well be a success , if it is it will grow to perhaps 8 teams and beyond, who knows what can happen when folk all push in the same direction.

 Lastly for those wondering what's happened to Ali Grieve. The Championship Committee which oversees the running of the Leagues has confirmed it will not allow Ali to play 1ST team rugby for us as he has played 3 games for Hawick and 1 as a dual registered player at Berwick. You can only play for two clubs in 1 season unless you receive written permission from them. Which is fine in terms of being regulated and stopping  someone being downright silly. His move back to us as a 1st team player has been refused . it looks like he will now play for Berwick. This isn't a SRU decision it’s an independent body run by the clubs which regulates on behalf of the Union.

In my personal opinion at a time when everyone is shouting about a shrinking game we have a choice. Be part of the problem or part of the solution. Personally I prefer to try and be part of the solution.


Time for a break - 05 Nov 2018

half term report - 01 Nov 2018

Holiday time - 26 Sep 2018

Happy Monday - 17 Sep 2018

Fast and Furious - 10 Sep 2018

Bit of a rant - 03 Sep 2018

New Season (2) - 29 Aug 2018

New Season (1) - 20 Aug 2018

NEW SEASON - 09 Jul 2018

One for the History Books - 21 May 2018

CHANGE - 05 May 2018

SIMPLY THE BEST - 29 Apr 2018

SIMPLY THE BEST (1) - 29 Apr 2018

CUP TIME - 24 Apr 2018

CHAMPIONS - 15 Apr 2018


Great Win--Huge Effort - 26 Mar 2018

CRUNCH TIME - 19 Mar 2018

Semi Final time - 12 Mar 2018

2nd time lucky - 30 Jan 2018

Off to the Seaside - 22 Jan 2018

TECNICAL HITCH - 18 Jan 2018

Fairy tales and Dreams - 20 Nov 2017

perfect 10 - 06 Nov 2017

9 FROM 9 - 31 Oct 2017


So far so good - 18 Oct 2017

Happy days - 02 Oct 2017

RUGBY UPDATE - 25 Sep 2017

Steady as we go - 20 Sep 2017

round 2 - 11 Sep 2017

ROUND 1 - 03 Sep 2017

New Signing - 05 Jul 2017

HERE WE GO AGAIN - 30 Jun 2017

Doddie Weir - 20 Jun 2017

Thanks to all - 23 Apr 2017


ITS MORE THAN A GAME - 12 Apr 2017

What an end to the season - 03 Apr 2017

24.2.17 - 24 Feb 2017

7.2.17 - 07 Feb 2017

29.1.17 - 29 Jan 2017

21-01-2017 - 21 Jan 2017

Winter has come... - 14 Jan 2017

  Melrose Rugby

The Greenyards, Melrose

Tel : 01896822993
Mail :